503 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 212.579.3100
503 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 212.579.3100
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

  • Slide 1 of 9
  • Slide 2 of 9
  • Slide 3 of 9
  • Slide 4 of 9
  • Slide 5 of 9
  • Slide 6 of 9
  • Slide 7 of 9
  • Slide 8 of 9
  • Slide 9 of 9

    • a close up of a logo

    Snacks

    • Cheesesteak Egg Roll

      Sirloin Steak, Sharp Cheddar, Onions, Jalapeno's, Horseradish Mayo

      $13

    • Mac & Cheese Pops

      Three Cheeses, Panko Crusted, Chipotle Aioli

      $12

    • Marinated Chicken Skewers

      Sambal, Ginger, Garlic, Honey

      $14

    • Jambalaya Kebabs

      Cajun Spiced Grilled Shrimp, Andouille Sausage, Blistered Shishitos

      $14

    • Shrimp Cocktail

      4 Jumbo Shrimp Served Chilled With Chef's Rockin' Cocktail Sauce

      $19

    • Tuna Poké Crisps

      Ahi Tuna, Avocado, Cucumber, Sesame Oil, Soy, Crushed Wasabi Peas, Chili Mayo, Crisp Wonton

      $19

    Starters

    • Chopped Romaine Wedge

      Romaine Lettuce, Applewood Bacon, Heirloom Cherry Tomatoes, Blue Cheese Dressing, Pickled Red Onion

      $15

    • Arugula Salad

      Candied Walnuts, Granny Smith Apples, Parmesan Cheese, Balsamic Vinaigrette

      $15

    • Roasted Red & Gold Beet Salad

      Goat Cheese, Pistachios, Baby Greens, Blood Orange Zest

      $15

    • Baylander’s Fish & Chip Tacos

      Beer Battered Cod, Crisp Matchstick Potatoes, Tartar Sauce, Pickled Red Onion, Flour Tortilla

      $16

    • Double Cut Bacon Steak

      Maple Glazed, Red Chile Grain Mustard

      $18

    • Lollipop Lamb Chops

      Frenched Australian Lamb Chops, Sweet Tamari Glaze, Pepper Flakes, Crispy Onions

      Each (2 Piece Min.) $12

    Mains

    • Lobster Truffle Risotto

      Poached Maine Lobster, Arborio Rice, Parmesan Reggiano, Basil, Truffle Essence

      $34

    • Murray’s Organic Half Chicken

      Pan Roasted, Mashed Potatoes, Steamed Broccolini, Whole Grain Mustard

      $27

    • Pan Seared Atlantic Salmon

      Blistered Cherry Tomatoes, Baby Spinach, Lemon Zest, Balsamic Reduction

      $28

    • ALASKAN HALIBUT

      Pan Roasted, Stir Fried Bok Choy, Shiitake Mushrooms, Yellow Tomato-Lemongrass Jalapeño Coulis

      $35

    • Steak Au Poivre

      12 oz. Angus Strip Steak, Three Peppercorn & Cognac Cream Sauce, Shoestring Fries

      $48

    • Alberto’s Crackling Pork Shank

      4 Hour Braised Shank, Crisped Skin, Apple-Ginger Chutney, Pickled Red Onions

      $39

    • Pesto Gnocchi

      Shitake Mushrooms, Grape Tomatoes, Parmesan, Crushed Red Pepper, Toasted Breadcrumbs

      $26

    • Prohibition Cheeseburger

      6 oz. Custom Beef Blend, Vermont Cheddar, Caramelized Onion & Tomato Jam, Dijon Mustard, Served on a Portuguese Sweet Roll, Parmesan Truffle Fries

      $25

    Sides

    • Crispy Parmesan Truffle Fries

      $12

    • Creamy Mashed Potatoes

      $8

    • Sautéed Broccolini, Garlic, Pepper Flakes

      $8

    • Steamed French Beans, Roasted Shallots

      $9

    "LITTLE PIE COMPANY" DessertS

    • "Pro" Pie (For 2)

      Served Warm, Vanilla Ice Cream

      $19

    • Mississippi Mud Pie

      Fresh Whipped Cream

      $10

    Specialty Cocktails

    • Prohibition's Frozen Cosmopolitan

      Skyy Infusions citrus vodka, triple sec, fresh lime, cranberry juice - FROZEN

      $16

    • Bootlegger Old Fashioned

      Sagamore rye whiskey, simple syrup, aromatic & orange bitters, brandied cherry

      $17

    • The Roaring ‘20s

      Empress 1908 gin, Italicus bergamot liqueur, fresh lemon, lavender bitters, Cinzano prosecco

      $17

    • Mickey Finn Margarita

      Casamigos Blanco, Casamigos Mezcal, Cointreau, watermelon puree, agave nectar, fresh lime

      $18

    • Smash and Grab

      Angel’s Envy port finished bourbon, Domaine de Canton ginger liqueur, muddled lemons, superfine sugar, candied ginger

      $18

    • The Button Man Martini

      Grey Goose vodka, hot & spicy pickle brine, pickle chips

      $17

    • Tom Cat Tonic

      Salcombe Rose Sainte Marie gin, Fever Tree mediterranean tonic water, fresh lemon, thyme

      $17

    • Packing Heat

      Patrón Reposado tequila, Chacho jalapeño aguardiente, Patron Citronge, blood orange juice, fresh lime, chilé salt

      $18

    • The Old Sport

      Elijah Craig bourbon, Dubonnet rouge, muddled mint, fresh lime, simple syrup, burlesque bitters

      $17

    • The Bearcat

      Grey Goose Essences white peach & rosemary vodka, Domaine de Canton ginger liqueur, fresh lime, Fever Tree ginger beer, torched rosemary

      $16

    • Miller’s crossing

      Martin Miller’s london dry gin, muddled basil, Pama pomegranate liqueur, St. Germain elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon

      $18

    • Hemingway Daiquiri

      Bacardi Superior rum, luxardo maraschino liqueur, fresh lime juice, simple syrup, fresh squeezed grapefruit juice

      $16

    • Giggle Water

      Espolòn Blanco tequila, fresh squeezed grapefruit juice, agave nectar, fresh lime, Fever Tree pink grapefruit soda, pink himalayan sea salt

      $17

    • The Real McCoy

      Sagamore rye whiskey, Carpano Antica Formula, Campari, orange bitters, hickory smoke

      $22

    • Tarantula Juice

      Ilegal Mezcal, Mr. Black cold brew liqueur, Grand Marnier, cold brew coffee, chocolate bitters

      $17

    • The Teetotaler (Non Alcoholic)

      Muddled mint, cucumber puree, fever tree ginger beer, fresh lime

      $9

    Draught Beer

    • Guinness

      $9

    • Lagunitas IPA

      $9

    • Stella Artois

      $9

    • Sam Adams Seasonal

      $9

    • Allagash White

      $9

    • Radeberger Pilsner

      $9

    • Founders All Day IPA

      $9

    • Bronx “Now Yous Can’t Leave” Double IPA

      $10

    • Delirium Tremens

      $10

    Bottled Beer

    • Heineken

      $8

    • Heineken 0.0 (n.a)

      $7

    • Corona Extra

      $8

    • Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA

      $8

    • Angry Orchard Crisp Cider

      $8

    • Brooklyn Cider Company Kinda Dry

      $8

    • Schofferhofer Grapefruit

      $8

    • Singlecut Kim Sour

      $9

    • Budweiser

      $7

    • Bud Light

      $7

    Bubbles

    • Prosecco

      Cinzano, Italy

      $12

      $42

    • Champagne

      Piper-Heidsieck Prohibition Edition

      $95

    • Champagne

      Veuve Clicquot, Brut, Yellow Label, Reims

      $145

    • Champagne

      Dom Perignon, Brut

      $350

    White & Rose

    • Pinot Grigio

      Leaping Horse, Lodi

      $12

      $42

    • Sauvignon Blanc

      Ferrari Carano, Sonoma County

      $13

      $46

    • Chardonnay

      J. Lohr, Arroyo Vista

      $15

      $54

    • Chardonnay

      Flowers, Sonoma Coast

      $90

    • Riesling

      Anthony Road, Semi-Dry, Finger Lakes

      $13

      $46

    • Rosé

      A to Z, Oregon

      $12

      $42

    • Rosé

      Saleya, Provence

      $14

      $50

    Red

    • Red Blend

      Kings of Prohibition, Australia

      $11

      $40

    • Pinot Noir

      Ironstone, Lodi

      $12

      $42

    • Pinot Noir

      Sea Sun, California

      $15

      $54

    • Pinot Noir

      Charles Krug, Carneros

      $59

    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      Bonanza by Caymus, California

      $16

      $58

    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      Justin, Paso Robles

      $75

    • Malbec

      Millbrandt, The Estates, Wahluke Slope

      $15

      $54

    • Petite Sirah

      Foppiano Vineyards, Russian River Valley

      $58

    • Merlot

      Decoy, Napa Valley

      $16

      $58

    • Zinfandel Blend

      Ridge, Three Valleys, Sonoma County

      $69

    • Zinfandel Blend

      Orin Swift, 8 Years in the Desert, California

      $90

    American Legends

    • Duckhorn, Merlot, Napa Valley, 2018

      $145

    • Paradigm, Cabernet Sauvignon, Oakville, Napa Valley, 2017

      $162

    • Stag’s Leap “Artemis” Napa Valley, 2010

      $225

    • Orin Swift “Papillon” Napa Valley, 2019

      $140

    • Silver Oak, Cabernet Sauvignon, Alexander Valley, 2017

      $180

    • Quintessa, Napa Valley, 2018

      $395

    • Caymus Special Selection, Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, 2017

      $425

    • Joseph Phelps “Insignia” Proprietary Blend, Napa Valley, 2018

      $470

    Stationary Choices

    • Prohibition Jumbo Pretzel Spicy Mustard

      (Cut or Whole)

    Passed Platters

    12 pieces per platter

    • Mini Cheeseburger Sliders on Martin’s Potato Rolls

      $35

    • Grilled Marinated Chicken Skewers, Sambal, Ginger, Garlic, Honey

      $35

    • Double Cut Bacon Steak, Maple Glaze, Red Chile Grain Mustard

      $35

    • Cheese Steak Egg Rolls with Horseradish Cream

      $39

    • Pigs in a Blanket w/ Spicy Mustard

      $30

    • Blackened Grilled Shrimp Skewers, Blistered Shishito, Lime

      $35

    • Fish & Chip Taco’s - Cod Fish & Shoestring Fries, Pico de Gallo, Tartar Sauce

      $35

    • Tuna Poke-Avocado, Teriyaki Marinade, Jalapeno Sliver, Spicy Mayo, Cucumber

      $39

    • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail w/ PROHIBITION'S Rockin' Cocktail Sauce

      $42

    • Veggie Potstickers, Sweet Chili Sauce

      $30

    • Caprese Skewers -Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil Skewers w/ a Balsamic Glaze

      $30

    • Grilled Vegetable Kebabs, Garlic Aioli

      $30

    • Quinoa & Artichoke Taco's, Salsa Verde, Corn Tortilla

      $35

    • Lollipop Lamb Chops, Sweet Tamari Glaze, Pepper Flakes

      $120

    Dessert Platters

    12 pieces per platter

    • Fresh Baked Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies

      $28

    • “il Laboratorio Del Gelato” Mini Vanilla Ice Cream Popsicles W/ Dark Chocolate

      $40

    • Mini Cupcakes

      Red velvet w/cream cheese icing, vanilla butter cream, chocolate chocolate

      $30

    Specialty Cocktails

    • Bootlegger Old Fashioned

      Sagamore rye whiskey, simple syrup, aromatic & orange bitters, brandied cherry

      $12

    • Prohibition's Frozen Cosmopolitan

      Skyy Infusions citrus vodka, triple sec, fresh lime, cranberry juice

      $12

    • Tom Cat Tonic

      Salcombe Rose Sainte Marie gin, Fever Tree mediterranean tonic water, fresh lime

      $12

    • The Bearcat

      Grey Goose Essences white peach & rosemary vodka, Domaine de Canton ginger liqueur, fresh lime, Fever Tree ginger beer, torched rosemary

      $16

    • Hemingway Daiquiri

      Bacardi Superior rum, Luxardo maraschino liqueur, fresh lime juice, simple syrup, fresh squeezed grapefruit juice

      $12

    • Giggle Water

      Espolòn Blanco tequila, fresh squeezed grapefruit juice, agave nectar, fresh lime, Fever Tree pink grapefruit soda, pink himalayan sea salt

      $12

    Draught Beer

    • Lagunitas IPA

      $6

    • Stella Artois

      $6

    • Sam Adams Seasonal

      $6

    • Allagash White

      $6

    • Radeberger Pilsner

      $6

    • Founders All Day IPA

      $6

    Wine

    • Prosecco-Cinzano, Italy

      $8

    • Pinot Grigio-Leaping Horse, Lodi, 2020

      $8

    • Rosé-Maison Saleya, 2021

      $8

    • Red Blend-Kings of Prohibition, Australia

      $8

    • Pinot Noir-Ironstone, Lodi, 2020

      $8

    Snacks

    • Giant Pretzel

      Warm with Dijon Mustard

      $10

    • Marinated Chicken Skewers

      Sambal, Ginger, Garlic Honey

      $10

    • Tuna Poke Crisps

      Ahi Tuna, Avocado, Cucumber, Sesame Oil, Soy, Crushed Wasabi Peas, Chili Mayo, Crispy Wontons

      $10

    • Caprese Skewers

      Fresh Mozzarella, Cherry Tomatoes, Basil, Balsamic Glaze

      $10

    • Truffle Fries

      Parmesan Cheese, Truffle Oil

      $10

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!